ISSUES


ABOUT

Editorial

Brit Barton



Maus II: A Survivor's Tale: And Here My Troubles Began by Art Spiegelman, 1991. Published by Pantheon




Of all the scenes and subtext in the new film Fatherland, it felt like the softest climax when Thomas Mann—the film’s aging and ambivalent antihero—tours through the ruins of Germany and finds himself faced with the mounted death mask of Goethe. All roads, avoided and not, had led up to this moment for the celebrated and beleaguered author. Staring straight at the mask of a figure who had likely been a shadow over his shoulder forever, it appears simply as a piece of plaster with ubiquitous facial features: soft indentations of the closed eyelids and their sunken-in sockets, a defined nose, thin lips, and poreless, refined cheeks that counter the crow’s feet wrinkles and heavy, furrowed brow. 

It was the symbolic apotheosis of Germany’s cultural epoch that, certainly by Mann’s visit then, and still very much so now, is over. I think. News that the far-right Alternative für Deutschland (AfD) party had obtained a predictable win in the eastern state of Saxony-Anhalt just pointed to what has been approaching for years now. Further results from the September elections did yield a decisive win for Die Linke in Berlin, wherein mayoral candidate Elif Eralp could potentially become the first leftist mayor of the capital since reunification—coalition willing. Na ja. Egal. This is all to say, Goethe’s death mask in the scene acts less like a reliquary and more like a memento mori for the country, the writer, and the audience alike.

I’m reading now that there is some debate over the legitimacy of this and all of Goethe’s supposed death masks throughout the world, which feels fitting. Provenance—let alone subject—can be fraudulent or forged, and Goethe explicitly wished not to have one made. A study suggests two “life masks” were made and copied much later, after death. But honestly…who gets to say, nearly two hundred years later, that this is his real likeness? Is it even really about that—the likeness? Or is it the object, the mask itself, that holds some mystical, material power of proximity? 

***

I don’t remember when the decision was made to make masks as the thematic point for the October issue. I guess I thought it would be appropriate timing, or at least a little funny. I did know that I wanted to co-edit the issue with the artist Max Guy, who has been obsessed with the theory of masks and maskmaking for as long as I’ve known him. 

He took the concept and ran with it in more practical terms of theater, drawing on the Japanese tradition of Nō: in which one mask represents an archetype of a character and, throughout the play, an actor can embody multiple archetypes or events as the mask is switched. But is it as simple for the writers who masquerade as the critics?

I double-checked. Merriam-Webster has thirteen definitions as a noun and nine as a verb for the word “mask.” For me, it isn’t something that immediately connotes an object to craft, to embody, to collect or to keep on display. The word holds a litany of meanings within its ephemeral, psychological senses. It is so laden within Jungian theory, disguised in Wittgenstein’s word games, and embedded in doublespeak. Not to mention the word mask has become a signifier for the contemporary political tensions around choice and the body, in addition to implications and self-diagnosis fads associated with “masking.” All of which I find completely fascinating, especially and including the mask as an object. 

I’ve been thinking of ways to collapse all meanings, through both the literal and the figurative.


*** 


In May, I was leaving the biennale and stopped to see the remains of St. Lucia—that one who’s always depicted with her eyes on a plate. I thought so much of her since I had been in Sicily months before, and in Istanbul the year before that. Her depictions are everywhere. The story is (supposedly, of course) that she was born in Ortigia and fought with her father over a marriage proposal since she decided to devote herself to God. She possibly gouged out her eyes to make herself ugly—or was tortured for refusing—died and obtained sainthood with her eyes miraculously intact. Her body was taken to Turkey, then stolen back to Italy, where she remains in a small chapel in Venice near the train station that bears her name. 

It's unassuming like most facades there; you wouldn’t know exactly what to expect unless you knew what you were looking for amid the hundreds of other churches, palazzos, or so. The grandeur, dilapidated or not, and its delusions are everywhere. I was so tired by then and so confused by what I had seen that week; I was overwhelmed by how little I cared about it compared to what else was weighing on my mind. The chapel as an intimate, quiet, ornate setting felt right. 

She was laid on a pedestal in the apse, encased in a vitrine and lit, heavily draped in red silk. Her face was covered over a polished metal plate, with a few simple marks meant to mimic the look of a sleeping woman, while her hair was full and detailed. The mask was slightly oversized to cover the reality of age, of death. 

Personally, I thought it was just awful. This poor woman—the Patron Saint of Sight or not—was laid to rest for all of us to witness as she withered away, absorbing all of our projections. A visitor could circle the case, survey the body from every angle, and come close to facing her with only a thin sheet of glass protecting her. Her feet were visible and unadorned, the tissue long gone from the last eight hundred years or whatever. I recalled the feeling of leaving the Catacombe dei Cappuccini in Palermo in March. I felt dizzy and had to sit.

Photography wasn’t allowed, and I’ve long been over the image, anyway. I sat in the pew for a while and decided to draw the scene. I thought about the necessary detachment in looking and the analytical, vaguely forensic process of drawing, of writing. How I would never fall for the myth of a martyr, of the con artist. Yet beside me in the first row pew was an older man weeping, holding on to his rosary and counting the beads, praying for the guiding sight of St. Lucia. 

I’m not exactly a fatalist. But maybe sometimes I am. I lit a candle, just in case, and left.




Thank you as always to the issue contributors, my co-editor Max Guy, and A&O Art Director Razi Hedström.  The forthcoming issue for December is Infrastructure/Infrastruktur and will be co-edited by Jennifer Teets.

Update: There is now a newsletter for new issue and event announcements. 



Brit Barton is an artist and writer based in Zurich. She is the editor of Art and Order Journal and founder of Relative Press.